The most recent allegations showing to contain Paul come from Makenna Gibbons, who was a part of that unique scandal however didn’t seem on the primary season of the fact present.

Gibbons dropped a five-part collection of movies on November 25 to her TikTok, the place she claimed that she and her then-husband solely briefly participated within the “soft-swinging” MomTok scandal that received uncovered.

She stated that each instances it was with an unnamed couple — confirmed to be Paul and her then-husband in subsequent movies as she and Paul started exchanging accusations and tossing receipts backwards and forwards over the following couple of days.

“We did swap companions and soft-swinging occurred,” Gibbons admitted firstly of her first video collection, saying that issues shortly modified for her when she seen her husband is perhaps catching emotions.

Gibbons stated her husband admitted that he and this companion — later confirmed to be Paul — “each acknowledge that we get alongside rather well and that issues might develop.” However as a result of they’re each blissful of their marriages, they “do not wish to go down that route.”

That was after the primary encounter, per Gibbons. After the second encounter, which Gibbons stated was additionally the final, she stated she advised him, “If that is what you need then we are able to divorce now, as a result of I will not take part.”

She additionally claimed she then spoke with the girl half of that couple, telling her that she and her husband have been completed with any type of “soft-swinging,” solely to purportedly discover out that not solely had her husband kissed this lady, however that they’d had intercourse.

She additional stated {that a} pal not solely advised her about Paul’s bodily intimacy along with her husband, but in addition that the pair had been assembly up “for a while,” declared their love, and have been apparently planning to depart their spouses for each other.

Paul seemingly confirmed not less than a part of this narrative when she first uncovered the “soft-swinging” MomTok scandal again in June 2022. At the moment, as famous by Individuals, she stated that she and her husband had an settlement of their open relationship to “not go all the way in which” or catch emotions.

She then admitted she “did step out of that settlement” and even fell in love with one of many husbands she was swinging with. If stated husband was Gibbons’, that will align with Gibbons’ declare that they’d declared love to 1 one other.

Again on September 4 of this 12 months, Paul advised The Viall Information that she had determined to talk out publicly after seeing a number of the different MomTokers liking feedback referring to her as a “cheater” and “husband stealer,” admitting she did not totally assume by what exposing the entire group would do, however eager to push again in opposition to that narrative.

“So I received on-line, not considering in any respect, however like, ‘Hey sure, I did do that, however we have been additionally all hooking up simply the opposite night time,’” she stated.

“It simply did not really feel prefer it was honest,” she added on the time. “There was much more to the story than simply I’m some type of house wrecker.”

As soon as once more, it seems to be like Paul is stepping in with “much more to the story,” this time in response to Gibbons’ preliminary five-part exposé about her experiences — which could not have named names, however was clearly pointing proper at Paul.

Leaping on the identical platform, Paul’s first TikTok pushed again at a few of Gibbons’ claims, with Paul writing that Gibbons “by no means requested to cease” the “soft-swinging” that was taking place. In reality, she claimed that Gibbons “was one of many instigators, and despatched HER husband to get me, however inform your facet sis.”

As La Roux’ “Bulletproof” performed within the background, she adopted up a video of her dancing with one in every of her and Gibbons kissing and laughing, then a photograph of her, Gibbons and presumably Gibbons’ then-husband (along with his face coated by a clown face emoji), and at last some chat alerts from April 2 that would appear to substantiate Gibbons was totally onboard with what was taking place.

Gibbons then responded to this video with one more TikTok the place she pulled her personal receipts (and began naming names), pushing again in opposition to the textual content screenshot Paul confirmed by providing a extra expansive screenshot of that change the place Gibbons expressed extra confusion and reservations than enthusiasm.

She additionally shared one other textual content dialog with Paul from that point, the place she wrote that she did not like feeling she was being painted as bisexual when she will not be — which is why she now feels it is odd that Taylor used video of them kissing as a part of her personal receipts.

Paul then responded once more with even higher element in one more follow-up video the place she stated that Gibbons’ rationalization of her April receipts within the above TikTok do not jive with a gaggle journey they’d all deliberate collectively in Might, the place they have been all purportedly nonetheless hashing out their boundaries.

“It is irritating after they’re all popping out to inform the reality and it is slightly little bit of, ‘I did not actually wish to do it,’ ‘I needed to cease,’ ‘I wasn’t having fun with it,’” Paul stated in her newest TikTok. “They loved it!”

She additionally stated that it was her ex who introduced the {couples} collectively and stated he needed it to cease — not Gibbons — as she’s been saying since she first broke this story.

“I owned my half, why cannot they personal willingly doing it and by no means voiced to cease?” she questioned within the caption of her video, whereas additionally saying this could be her remaining feedback about it.

We’ll simply have to attend and see if that is true about both Paul or Gibbons.

Paul will probably be again when The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives returns for its second season. Gibbons, in the meantime, stated in her movies that she’s been requested many instances to be a part of the present, however has turned them down every time.